But can you imagine any of those people giving valuable critiques?! They've all had major meltdowns, something people on AI should really be trying to steer clear of.
The first qualification to be a judge can't be whether someone has never flopped, it should be about the quality of their comments, right?!
And say what you want about J. Lo's music career, she's had plenty of success and some really great music. Of course not as much recently, but Mariah and Whitney aren't perfeming like they used to either (chartwise or personally.)